How I Eliminated Binge Eating Completely

by JC on March 2, 2009

Post image for How I Eliminated Binge Eating Completely

Creative Commons License photo credit: audrey_sel

Binge Eating according to Wikipedia is a pattern of disordered eating which consists of episodes of uncontrollable overeating.

The Problem

Binge eating is a fairly common issue in the bodybuilding and fitness circle. I myself have experienced the woes of this disorder as have many others I know and have worked with personally. Now I believe there to be two different scenarios to Binge Eating. First you have the small group of fitness enthusiasts who have mini binges and then you have people who experience severe psychological issues with food. The latter group typically will struggle with the disorder for a prolonged period of time and often take drastic measures to compensate for their actions. If you are reading this and you are in the second group, I highly recommend seeking professional help.

This article is mainly for the fitness enthusiast who, like myself has struggled with binge eating in the past.

How I Got Into Trouble

It all started about four years ago when I began counting calories. I was brainwashed into the whole “clean” food phenomenon as I was reading every bodybuilding and fitness related magazine I could get my meat hooks on. I was so obsessed with the “you gotta eat clean, bro!” mentality that I threw all other sanity to the wind. I was immediately obsessed with brown rice, oatmeal, natural peanut butter, lean chicken breast etc. I was basically consuming most of the foods deemed “clean” by the infamous, dogma laden health and fitness community. I somehow adopted the assumption that pizza, burgers, pasta, white bread and any other fast or “dirty” food would only be stored as fat and would be suboptimal in terms of energy needs.

This wasn’t so bad when on a bulking diet because I was eating plenty of food and keeping full most of the time. However I was developing a really sour relationship with food. I began to look down on others who ate out and those who ordered pizza instead of cooking a chicken breast and brown rice. I found myself constantly craving the food I was restricting. The main reasons were because I could not count the calories and because I assumed it would go straight to my gut. I also began to feel superior to my peers for my abstinence of unhealthy food.

It Only Got Worse

As I said the bingeing wasn’t too much of a problem when on a bulking diet. On a fat loss diet though, it was my worst nightmare. While I found myself severely restricting my intake, I decided to allow one cheat meal per week. This was an absolute disaster. I would eat “clean” all week long and end up almost completely reversing my previous weeks efforts on Sunday. It would start with a breakfast of lots and lots of bacon, eggs and hash browns soaked in grease. Then for lunch I would pig out on whatever was around. May be some peanut butter and jelly, cookies or whatever I could find that was “dirty.” Then for dinner it was usually a race to see how sick I could make myself. I would eat an entire pizza, then I would top it off with ice cream, brownies, cookies and anything else sugary I could get my paws on. I literally ate myself sick on many occasions. The next few days were often filled with overexercising, calorie restriction and feelings of guilt and anxiety. The mirror wasn’t flattering as I usually was holding a ton of water and the scale always revealed an 8-10lb weight swing.

What Did I Do?

I went to a therapist, got religion and joined a convent. I kid. I did however seek help, although not through traditional methods. I sought help through self-study and personal research. I knew that what I was doing was unhealthy and could not be maintained long term. I began seeking out those in the field who were smarter and more experienced than I.  I looked to Lyle McDonald for the science behind nutrition and macro composition. Everything I could read about science based nutrition, I read. I soon found that in theory, a calorie is just a calorie. If calories can be controlled, it doesn’t make an iota of difference as to what effects they will have on body composition. When I say calories I am more so referring to energy calories such as carbohydrates and fat. Of course protein is required to maintain lean body mass, but once a certain minimum of protein is met, the other calories are simply used for energy.

So I had to make a decision. I could believe all the old school dogma that was leading to my bingeing or I could adopt a new mindset and belief system around food and change my life for the better.

My Experiment

I began controlling my calories but allowing myself to eat the foods I was craving more often. For instance instead of a boring chicken breast and brown rice I had a few slices of pizza and then a protein shake to meet my protein requirements. For breakfast I would eat the same amount of carbs in the form of sugary cereal as opposed to plain oatmeal. I did this for a couple of months to gather my thoughts and collect data. What did I discover? Food choices do not make a difference at all as long as calories are controlled. A calorie is a calorie. I also lowered my meal frequency to about 2-3 meals a day instead of 6-8. This allowed for better satiety with each meal. I found that I no longer had the urge to binge anymore.

How To Eliminate Binge Eating in 3 Easy Steps

Make A Choice – Decide you want to stop this behavior and make a plan to do so.

  • Decide the route you are going to take. Plan your work and work your plan.
  • Do not give up if you fail at first. You will not conquer this habit over night.

Experiment - Try new approaches until you find something that works for you.

  • Experiment with Intermittent Fasting and place most of your food around workouts or later in the evening. This will provide more satiety and I have had great success with IFing.
  • Manipulate your energy macros. If carbs tend to make you ravenous, switch to a lower carb diet and eat more fat as fat is known to be a bit more satiating. If you like to pig out on fatty foods, switch to a higher carb diet with most of the energy coming from fruits and veggies.
  • Try different strategies until one sticks.

Seek Accountability - Make sure others know what you are doing and what your goals are.

  • Tell your friends that you are committing to this. Ask them to check up on you every so often.
  • Write in a journal daily or start a blog to document your progress. Many have started weight loss blogs for nothing else but accountability. John from JohnIsFit is a perfect example. He recently wrote a piece on Binge Eating as well.
  • If all else fails, get help. There is no shame in asking for help.

If there is anything I can do to assist you, feel free to contact me directly. I am always open to helping in any way that I can. If you have conquered binge eating, how did you go about it?

Leave a Comment

JC August 19, 2010 at 7:33 pm

Yes, I’ve heard of it.

I think the RFL is a much better option simply because Lyle has you eating whole foods which will be more filling + help you maintain better eating habits.

Reply

Gus August 19, 2010 at 5:46 pm

Hey man have you ever heard of the velocity diet? Similar to the “anaconda protocol” (I think all of us have read about that insanity whatsoever), its another T-nation thing. I looked at the diet and its liquid nutrition all the way with only one meal per week, and it has to be like a body builder meal. What do you personally think about this diet? i feel like this is kind of similar to Lyle Mcdonald’s rapid fat loss diet where you just eat protein and veggies but even the rapid fat loss diet seems lenient compared to the v diet.

Reply

JC August 19, 2010 at 1:25 pm

What’s up Joe?

My take is this. Life is too short to worry about eating clean for the rest of your life. Do some people do it all the time? Probably.

Is it sustainable? Most likely not for the majority.

Then again everyone seems to have a different view of what’s clean and what’s not. I hate the word, actually, when referring to our diets.

To me, it’s just all about balance. Eat some fruit, veggies, lean protein and have dessert now and again. As long as you maintain an active lifestyle, focus on getting it right 80-90% of the time, you’ll have very little to worry about, IMHO.

Reply

joe August 19, 2010 at 12:47 pm

Hey JC, i was wondering what’s ur take on some people who claim they eat clean all the time? i mean junk food is obviously bad for u, but sometimes i feel like these clean eating ppl are taking things to the extreme

Reply

Marcus May 8, 2010 at 9:01 am

What if I’m hungry on a bulk, and I’m feeling the urge do binge? Would it be OK to do it?

Thanks.

Reply

JC May 9, 2010 at 8:05 am

I would say no for 2 reasons.

1. It only helps to create a bad habit
2. It’s a good way to get unnecessarily fat.

Reply

G April 6, 2010 at 7:34 pm

I really appreciate the article, the website, and work you’ve done. It’s nice to see men talking about eating and their relationship with food once an awhile. All too often, the focus is entirely devoted to women and girls. There truly needs to be a universal approach to this health issue rather than a micro examination of the popular and culturally attractive norms we have come to associate eating disorders with.

Reply

Travis March 29, 2010 at 9:18 am

I’m not sure I’ve ever binged that extremely, but there have been plenty of times when I’ll get off work from a long day, having watched my food intake all week, only to completely eat junk food until I go to bed that night. Of course, this puts a huge damper on all my hard work during the week. Needless to say, I end up going to sleep feeling like complete crap and feeling guilty as hell too. I’ve since gotten much better, but I think restricting ALL your favorite foods only makes things worse; as the cravings only get more and more intense.

Reply

JC March 29, 2010 at 3:18 pm

I agree completely with regards to the whole guilt thing. I always try to incorporate the more desirable food into any diet to keep those cravings at bay.

Reply

Mike February 24, 2010 at 6:43 pm

Wow, this is a great post your early on dieting “clean” foods thing and binge eating on Sunday till you feel sick and reversing all the previous weeks work is exactly what I have been doing for close to 6 monthes now. I get pretty cut by Friday and Saturday and blow it all Saturday or Sunday. Over and over again. I realize it’s completely unhealthy and a waste of time but by the end of the weak my will power is gone from exercise and fasting/restricting calories and food. I hope this post will help me improve in the future.

Thanks

Reply

JC February 24, 2010 at 8:17 pm

this is where moderation comes into play. I’m sure there are many others out there like yourself who’ve been struggling the same. I’m glad I could be of some help

Reply

Esther September 17, 2009 at 1:22 am

Hi JC,
thank you for posting this. Right now, I have gone through 2 days of extreme 6,000 calorie binges, and I am sitting here in pain, face extremely swollen, and ready to go to sleep with an exploding stomache, knowing that I am going to wake up with a still full, bloated, cramped, painful stomache, and a body shaking with hunger due to the sugar rush (I ate boxes and boxes of cereal, cookies, pizza, a whole loaf of bread, bags of chocolate in a matter of a couple of days). I suffer from Binge Eating Disorder, but had successfully controlled it this summer. But because I am so obsessed with “clean-eating”, my body feels deprive and it has taken a toll on my cravings (I have been eating everything and anything i can get my hands on these past couple days). I don’t want to go back to gaining 40 pounds in a year again. I want it to stop now. But tomorrow I know i will be EXTREMELY down and I feel like everything I have worked so hard for is now gone forever. What do you think I should do tomorrow (the stress of working out also gets me to binge) and will I be okay?

Reply

JC September 17, 2009 at 5:36 am

Esther, I am not an expert on eating disorders. What I suffered from was a mild case of binge eating.

I would suggest seeking a medical professional who deals with these types of behavioral issues.

best of luck

Reply

Esther September 17, 2009 at 12:00 pm

This has been going on for two years now. I was anorexic before and because I entered college and lost all control of my eating habits, i gained 40 pounds in one year. Last night and the other night are very reminiscent of my binge episodes during the school year (they were actually worse). As of right now, I woke up and am feeling extremely swollen and I don’t know what to do. Wake up, feel depressed, eat some more, get back on my binge eating episodes. I can’t find the motivation to try to fight it.

I am thinking about seeking help from the counselors at my school’s health center, but I’m unsure if they will be able to help.

Reply

JC September 17, 2009 at 1:52 pm

I can’t find the motivation to try to fight it.

this is exactly why you need to seek professional help. I do not mean to sound rude BUT I am not a doctor. I cannot assist you with seeking a cure. Please get help.

Reply

Nicole March 27, 2010 at 9:34 pm

This may come a bit late, but Overeaters Anonymous is a good place to start for anyone seeking help with BED or any other eating disorder. It’s basically free therapy and available in most cities and many different countries (check their website)

Reply

JC March 28, 2010 at 8:58 am

no problem… thanks for the info, Nicole. Never heard of BED.

Reply

Christine July 15, 2009 at 9:48 am

Do you have any advice on figuring out how many calories to eat? How to estimate your calories for things like pizza when you eat it out? Also, when you eat only 2-3 meals/day, do you evenly space out your meals?

Reply

JC July 15, 2009 at 9:58 am

Yup. The best way is to take a set amount o kcals, eat that for a few weeks, take notes and see what happens with regards to your weight in terms of changes etc.

For instance if you are fairly active(about an hour of activity per day which can include causal walking, gym time etc) you could start with 14-15xbw in lbs. That is a rough estimate for your daily kcal needs.

you would monitor this intake over 2 weeks. if you gain weight you adjust downwards, if you lose weight, you adjust upwards slightly.

Reply

julie May 31, 2009 at 5:58 pm

I did something similar to you, I declared all foods good for eating, and made sure I ate enough of the healthy ones that I didn’t crave the less healthy ones very often. I do not allow myself to feel guilty about food, either eaten or not. As a matter of fact, I ambush any guilt by deliberately eating something that makes me come out of that mindset.

BTW, that first comment, from James, that is a joke, right? That’s the worst bit of diet advice I’ve ever heard in my life. If I listened to logic like that, I’d be size 36 up from 18, rather than down to 10 and dropping.

Reply

JC May 31, 2009 at 6:35 pm

I just decided that food is only energy and it’s a waste of time to worry about the small stuff in life. besides I really like ice cream.

I am not sure if james was joking or not.

Reply

JC March 7, 2009 at 12:56 am

JMo87:

Thanks for your commentary. I too have been in that same sea of self-hate where I would go for so long without anything satisfying that I would go nuts on candy, cakes, fried food etc to a point of being sick.

The main reason I wrote this piece is because of the fact that I know there are many others out there who struggle with this same issue. While I have never suffered from a full blown disorder, I know that I can relate to many people. Most others outside of the health and fitness circle don’t have a clue that us fitness folk, who supposedly have it together regarding diet and nutrition would struggle with our eating habits. I have read and heard about many RD’s having eating disorders as well.

I am glad you liked the article and hope it helped you in some way.

Reply

JMo87 March 6, 2009 at 10:13 pm

JC thank you so much for writing this piece. I think eating disorders are so prevalent within the fitness community, but nobody talks about them because it’s often seen as something only teenage girls have issues with.

I struggled with binge eating myself for months after an intense dieting phase. I didn’t know what was happening to me, because I had always prided myself on my ability to abstain from “unclean” foods. Yet, after weeks and weeks of sub-maintenance calories, it seemed I could no longer control myself around food. I would often binge eat late at night on whatever I could get my hands on.

Thanks to listening to experts like Lyle McDonald and others, I’ve learned that there’s no magic to “eating clean”, and I CAN eat what I want (not just chicken and broccoli), provided I keep my calories in check.

Anyway, thank you for calling attention to this issue, as there seem to be more and more people (especially online) that are clearly suffering from an unhealthy relationship with their food.

Reply

JC March 2, 2009 at 4:14 pm

Skyler, I am simply not a fan of Dr Dardens protein requirements in his book The New HIT.

Reply

Skyler Tanner March 2, 2009 at 3:33 pm

JC,

I found the same thing when intermittent fasting, that as long as calories were kept in check and protein needs satisfied, I could feed on chocolate and ice cream…didn’t make a difference. I’d also like to note that, while you don’t agree with Doc Darden, he’s of the same opinion.

Best,
Skyler

Reply

JC March 2, 2009 at 11:55 am

Dawn: I have been the same person at those parties, so I know exactly how you feel. I feel its very important to keep those “unclean”(how I hate that word!) foods in your diet.

A diet shouldn’t be boring or depriving as that only leads to undesirable consequences.

Reply

dawn March 2, 2009 at 11:50 am

I’ve experienced this binge-following-deprivation as well. For example, I will go to a party and “behave” so well at the party that by the time I get home I’m so frustrated I’ll eat every “bad” thing in sight. It’s demoralizing. Currently I’m doing something similar to you in that I just allow myself treats and such, within my calorie allotment. I find that, given permission, the treats are not quite so tempting. Last night I was debating b/w a Milky Way and a bowl of cereal with sugar. It’d been a long time since I’d had something as bad as a candy bar, but I really wanted the cereal. So I went with that.

Reply

JC March 2, 2009 at 9:59 am

yes, on a diet you should be hungry. You may not be hungry all the time, but it’s pretty much a given. The whole goal is to manage that hunger in a way that allows you to drop the fat optimally without completely depriving yourself.

Reply

James March 2, 2009 at 9:25 am

I have the opposite problem! I never get ENOUGH calories! If only I could use these tips in reverse to create a binge effect after every workout.

Though for people who I’ve advised on how to lose weight, I’ve told them that weight loss is not easy, you WILL feel like binging ALL the time, and whenever you get that feeling, you KNOW that you’re succeeding in your goal to lose weight. The stronger the feeling of wanting to binge, the faster you’re going to achieve your goal.

Reply

Nicole March 27, 2010 at 8:15 pm

Try a post workout joint. It’s the only way my skinny bastard boyfriend can handle bulking!

And if you’re not one for smoking, get a vaporizer.

Reply